← All stories

Selling a Nashville Lot to a Builder vs. Listing With an Agent

Patrizio Murdocca
Selling a Nashville Lot to a Builder vs. Listing With an Agent

We have bought lots from owners who found May Construction through our website and reached out directly. That route can work well if you know what comparable lots are selling for and are willing to contact builders and evaluate their offers. If you are unsure about pricing or want help marketing and negotiating the sale, my advice is to list with a qualified agent who has a proven record of selling lots.

If you are selling a home in Nashville or Brentwood, you may already be wondering whether the next buyer will live in it or tear it down. That question affects who you approach, how you price it and what an agent needs to know.

Start with what is happening around your property

If nearby houses keep selling and then being torn down, you have a reason to investigate the value of your land. Look at those sales alongside the size and shape of your lot. An older home in an area with substantial new construction may attract builders even if someone could still live in it.

That can be a difficult conversation when you have lived in the house for years. A builder is evaluating a different use for the property. The pattern on your street is a starting point for that discussion, not a valuation of your particular lot.

For a closer look at what affects buildability, our Nashville lot feasibility guide covers setbacks, easements, utilities and slope.

Aerial view of three gray Forest Park homes during construction, with unfinished driveways and surrounding neighborhood visible.

May's Forest Park project during construction. The aerial view shows the homes within their surrounding neighborhood.

Selling directly to a builder

A direct sale may reduce brokerage costs. How much you would save depends on the agreements involved. Commissions are negotiable, and there is no required commission rate. The NAR consumer guide to listing agreements explains how compensation and services are agreed upon. If you have already signed a listing agreement, understand your obligations before assuming a direct buyer eliminates a fee.

The two mistakes I would watch for are asking a price that comparable lot sales do not support and accepting an offer without understanding who is buying.

Keep the asking price grounded in lot sales

A builder is an investor-buyer. The numbers have to work for the home they expect to build, so the asking price needs to make sense in the local lot market. A larger lot or another genuinely useful feature may justify a difference, but be able to explain that difference.

Trying to save a commission while asking far more than comparable properties have sold for can leave you with a property that sits. Listing with an agent does not solve an unrealistic asking price either.

Know whether you are dealing with the builder

Wholesalers have offered properties to us, and I have sometimes wondered whether the original owners understood the arrangement. A wholesaler may contract to buy a property and then assign that contract, or buy and resell the property, to a builder. That is a different arrangement from selling directly to the company that plans to build.

Ask who will sign the purchase agreement, who intends to close, and whether the buyer plans to assign the contract or resell the property. Understand how they would be paid. Have your own attorney review terms you do not understand before signing.

To find builders, look at who is actually building near you. Review their projects and contact them through their websites. Our Forest Park project is one example of the work you can examine when getting to know May. Use that conversation to ask whether your property fits the kind of home they build.

Choosing an agent who can sell a teardown lot

A good agent can help you reach buyers, handle inquiries and negotiate. For a potential teardown, I would look for a reputable brokerage and an agent with demonstrated experience selling land and working with builders.

Ask them:

  • Which lots or teardown properties have you sold recently?

  • How will you market this property to builders?

  • How will you handle questions about the lot and any due diligence already completed?

  • What services and compensation would our listing agreement include?

Responsiveness matters. When a builder calls, the agent needs to answer, understand the opportunity and know which questions still need investigation. Marketing the property only as a move-in-ready home can miss buyers who are evaluating it for redevelopment.

Make the lot opportunity easy to find

I often see potential teardown properties presented only as residential listings. Ask your agent whether the property can appropriately be marketed in both residential and land categories under the local MLS rules. Have them confirm the permitted approach for your property. The goal is to make its potential clear to builders searching for land, while accurately describing the existing house.

Compare what each offer actually means for you

Before accepting a lot offer: know who is buying, check comparable sales, compare costs and conditions, and confirm the closing timeline.

Put the proposed price beside the costs you would pay, the buyer's conditions and the closing date. Ask what could allow the buyer to withdraw and when those conditions must be resolved. A direct offer and an offer brought through an agent may differ on all of those points.

To discuss a potential sale to May, tell us about your lot. Share the property address, neighborhood and your preferred timing. Our acquisitions team can discuss the property with you and explain the next steps.

Common questions

Questions, answered

Should I sell my Nashville lot directly to a builder or use an agent?
A direct sale can work if you can research comparable lot sales, contact builders and evaluate their offers. If you want help with pricing, exposure and negotiation, I recommend an agent with a proven record of selling lots and working with builders.
Will selling directly to a builder eliminate commissions and closing costs?
A direct sale may reduce brokerage costs, but it does not automatically remove existing obligations or other closing costs. Compensation is negotiable. Ask for the costs you would pay and the purchase conditions in writing so you can compare what each offer would leave you with.
How can I tell whether the buyer is a builder or a wholesaler?
Ask who will sign the purchase agreement, who intends to close, and whether they plan to build, assign the contract or resell the property. Review the company's actual projects and have your own attorney explain any contract terms you do not understand.
How do I ask May Construction to consider my property?
Use the Sell Your Lot form to share the property address, neighborhood and preferred timing. May considers older homes as well as lot opportunities, including properties that are still occupied. Our acquisitions team can discuss fit and next steps. An offer depends on the particular site and what can responsibly be built there.
From the field